Peyton Manning is a free agent.
Words that you never thought you would hear. But it’s true. So now the big question is: where will he be
playing next season? I decided to look
over the entire NFL to help me form an opinion.
I understand that money and the salary cap may put several teams out of
the running. But in most of professional
sports leagues, teams somehow seem to find a way to make it magically occur. See David Stern versus the LA Lakers for the
other side of that story.
First of all you can quickly eliminate the five teams that have elite
quarterbacks who have won a Super Bowl:
New York Giants (Eli), New England Patriots (Brady), New Orleans Saints
(Brees), Green Bay Packers (Rodgers) and the Pittsburgh Steelers (Big Ben). These teams have no need for Manning. Let’s also remember that Peyton is getting
older and doesn’t have too many years left, so he does not want to go to a bad
team. He wants another Super Bowl and
soon. With that in mind, we can also
eliminate the Cleveland Browns, Jacksonville Jaguars, St. Louis Rams and of
course the Colts.
As for the rest of the league, we’ll go team by team.
AFC
East
Buffalo Bills: Not likely.
The weather is too cold. Peyton doesn’t
want to go from playing in a dome to playing in the snow and below freezing
temperature.
Miami Dolphins: A good possibility. The Dolphins have a good core of offensive
players. They developed a running game
in the second half of the season. There
are a few good wide receivers on the team.
Most importantly, the Dolphins have a good defense. The weather doesn’t hurt either. There won’t be too many home games where long
sleeves are needed.
New York Jets: I just don’t see this happening. Rex Ryan has too big of an ego. If Peyton goes to the Jets and they win the
Super Bowl, Ryan will not be able to handle not being able to take full credit
for the victory. The Jets will make a
play, just because they are New York and they need to keep their fans
happy. They also have some good selling
points, which include a top-notch defense, decent receivers and an
above-average running game.
AFC
North
Baltimore Ravens: It’s not going to happen, but I’m not sure it’s
too far-fetched. Joe Flacco has been
fairly consistent, but he tends to take a majority of the heat for the Ravens
not making it to the next level. Flacco
can be amazing one game and awful the next.
Cincinnati Bengals: Not going to happen. This is a young team looking towards the
future. I doubt that they even make an
offer.
AFC
South
Houston Texans: The Texans say that they’re happy with Matt
Schaub. But could you imagine Manning on
this team, with that defense, and arguably the best running back (Arian Foster)
and wide receiver (Andre Johnson) in the NFL.
That would be a scary team
Tennessee Titans: Doubtful.
I almost put this team on the bad team list, but they always seem to
linger near the middle to top of the division.
Put Manning on that team and who knows.
We all know what happened to the Colts when they didn’t have Peyton.
AFC
West
Denver Broncos: The Broncos were the first team to state that
they want Manning. The negatives are an
okay defense, cold weather and a young receiving core. The positives are the strong running game and
the weak division. I guess the plan
would be to use Tim Tebow in certain situations, but I don’t see Manning buying
into that idea.
Kansas City Chiefs: I can’t think of any reason anyone would want
to play for the Chiefs, but they are consistently mentioned as a
possibility. They have a good
defense. The running game is not good,
but could improve depending on how Jamaal Charles returns from injury. The receiving core is okay. They would probably have to get another
receiver to make Manning happy.
Oakland Raiders: My wish.
Unfortunately, the Raiders have spent too much for the three
quarterbacks on the roster (Carson Palmer, Jason Campbell and Terrelle Pryor). There are a lot of positives though: a good
defense, very strong running game, and young fast receivers.
San Diego Chargers: Not a chance.
The Chargers are committed to Philip Rivers, who is a borderline elite
quarterback. He just has his moments
when he is terrible.
NFC
East
Dallas Cowboys: You never know when it comes to Jerry Jones. Tony Romo is overrated and does not have the
ability to win the big games. Jones
wants to win at whatever the cost.
Philadelphia Eagles: Not a chance.
Michael Vick is the quarterback in Philly and the offense is built
around his ability to make plays. Peyton
is far from a mobile quarterback.
Washington Redskins: Supposedly one of the front runners. Though I think this is based on the fact that
Daniel Snyder is always willing to open his checkbook for any player (see:
Albert Haynesworth). I just don’t think
they have the assets that Peyton is looking for. They have an average defense, average running
game and below average receivers. Plus
the Pro Bowl quality tight end likes to smoke marijuana, a lot.
NFC
South
Atlanta Falcons: Not going to happen. Matt Ryan has been successful in the regular
season. He has not been good in the
playoffs, but he is still very young.
Carolina Panthers: Not going to happen. Cam Newton had a great year at quarterback as
a rookie. There is no reason to mess
with that. The Panthers need to look to
add other positions to better their team.
Tampa Bay Bucs: Not likely.
This is another borderline bad team, but they were decent two years ago. The weather is good, defense is decent and a
good running game. The receivers are
terrible.
NFC
North
Chicago Bears: Not going to happen. Too cold in Chicago, plus the Bears seem to
like Jay Cutler right now.
Detroit Lions: Not going to happen. The Lions are another young team looking
towards the future, with their young quarterback, Matthew Stafford. Stafford had a very strong year for the
Lions. The Lions need to mature and
improve their secondary.
Minnesota Vikings: Doubtful.
The Vikings already tried bringing in the veteran quarterback to lead
them to the Promised Land. It didn’t
work. I think they are missing too many
parts to lure Manning away from any of the front runners.
NFC
West
Arizona Cardinals: Another team that is supposedly a front
runner, but I don’t really understand why.
The team was bad last year. Larry
Fitzgerald is an amazing wide receiver, but there are other great receivers out
there too. The weather is good. The Cardinals were in a Super Bowl 3 years
ago, but they also went 9-7 in the regular season that same year.
San Francisco 49ers: Like the Texans, adding Manning to this team
would make them an instant favorite to win the Super Bowl. The main questions revolve around Alex
Smith. He was good at times, but he was
terrible in the NFC Championship. Are
the 49ers willing to take the chance of messing with Smith’s confidence by
putting their name in the hat? From
Manning’s point of view, the 49ers have a lot going for them. They were a couple of bad punt returns from
going to the Super Bowl. They have a strong defense, a very likeable coach, a
strong running game and a good receiving tight end. The wide receivers could be upgraded though.
Seattle Seahawks: A possibility. The Seahawks have a great running back and a
good young receiving core. Their defense
is scary and can score as much as the offense.
The players seem to like playing for Pete Carroll, who can run a pretty
dynamic offense.
The next couple of weeks are going to be very interesting. I personally believe that Manning will go to
Miami. I am usually wrong at these
decisions (I thought Lebron was staying in Cleveland and Favre was truly
retiring). Regardless of where Peyton
Manning plays next year, one thing is for certain, he will play hard and always
put his team in a position to win the game.
~Brad